|
1. Solution Approach to the Problem |
|
The solution does not address the requirements for the given Industry/Ministry’s problem. The solution only solves a generic technical / IT problem |
|
The solution partly addresses the given Industry/ Ministry’s problem. The chosen approach is basic with many known available solutions. |
|
The solution provides a unique approach to the Industry/ Ministry’s problem, but it may not be extendable into a platform for larger impact. The team has focused entirely on solving the specified problem in hand. |
|
The solution completely drives new business model/social engagement using software/technology driven methodology for the specific domain (e.g. what Uber/Paytm did in their domain). The solution has the capability to extend into a platform for larger Impact. The team has thought through the problem to the end and considered all aspects pertaining to the solution. |
|
2. Ambitiousness/Complexity/Impact Factor |
|
Simple problem statement requiring very little technical input (e.g. building an App with very little server side components OR building a simple Web page/Website). |
|
Medium Ambitious problem, requires a reasonable effort on both client side and server side. For the Ministry, the problem is real and they welcome the solution, but it is not an immediate/Top priority to address. |
|
Fairly Complex problem – requires significant effort on client and server sides. Team has demonstrated their Ambitiousness by selecting to work on the problem. The team has implemented a small subset of the problem and hence its impact to the Industry/ Ministry is minimal. Significant additional effort is needed to implement the solution for the Industry/ Ministry. |
|
Fairly Complex problem and team has implemented a significant subset of the problem. Problem is very important to the Ministry and the Ministry can Implement the Solution with minimal additional efforts. |
|
3. Technology and Innovations Attributes |
|
Not an innovative solution, it is regular web portal or desktop app. |
|
Solution is innovative and uses concepts like mobile first/cloud first and API level integrations. |
|
Solution has been innovatively designed using latest technologies e.g. India-stack, block-chain, machine learning, data insights, human machine interface etc. |
|
Solution is well thought out and is something extremely unique. It has very innovative approach - effective use of multiple latest technologies (e.g. listed above). |
|
4. Execution Attributes |
|
No working demo Few screens but not integrated |
|
Partial working demo to be able to showcase solution to the problem. Integration of code/development was there but not end to end. Demoed multiple parts separately. |
|
Usable and working demo however it was small and felt some development missing. Some of NFRs (Security, Performance) are also considered while implementation |
|
Completely working prototype of demo which can be repetitively executed (significant amount of coding or development might have gone in place). Most of NFRs (Security, Performance) considered while implementation
|
|
5. User Experience Attributes |
|
Not Useful – Personas(*), journey map not defined Not Usable - Confusing navigation, too many clicks, poor execution of UI Not Desirable - Negative first impression, will not motivate personas / users * Personas - Personas are fictional characters created to represent the different user types that might use a site, brand, or product in a similar way. |
|
Partly Useful - Personas identified but not clearly detailed out Partly Usable - Confusing navigation, too many clicks, average execution of UI Partly Desirable - Average first impression, just another app for personas / users |
|
Useful - Detailed Personas (one or many), detailed journey maps Usable - Easy to navigate, simple layouts, followed UI patterns, efficient for users Desirable - Positive first impression, will motivate personas / users |
|
Extremely Useful - Well detailed Personas (one or many), detailed journey maps Extremely Usable - Super easy to navigation, followed UI patterns, efficient for users Extremely Desirable - Very positive first impression, will certainly motivate personas / users |